Exploring the Options for Theater in Lancaster, PA

If you're planning a vacation to Lancaster, PA, you're in for a treat. Every year millions of people visit Lancaster, and record numbers of people spent their vacation in the city in 2021. Amish food, culture, and a small-town feel make Lancaster a unique vacation spot you won't forget.

But Lancaster also has a rich theater history, and you can find some of the most unique and memorable theater shows. To experience the best theater in Lancaster, PA, you'll need to learn more about the amazing venues Lancaster has to choose from.

Keep reading this guide to learn about the best theater options in Lancaster, PA!

Sight & Sound Theatre

Sight & Sound is a popular theater nationwide that performs theatric shows based on biblical themes. It has theaters in Lancaster, PA, and Branson, MO, with a history dating back 40 years.

The founder Glenn Eshelman grew up on a dairy farm and began painting landscapes. From there, he bought a camera to take pictures for his paintings.

A passion was born, and he began selling his artwork and using a slide projector to present his pictures with musical themes. After an overwhelming response, the idea of Sight & Sound came to life.

In Lancaster, you can buy tickets to watch the story of MOSES and follow along his journey. If you're going close to the holiday season, the Miracle of Christmas is a great option, highlighting the story of Mary and Joseph.

Tickets cost around $89, but you'll need to verify this when you book.

American Music Theatre

If you're looking for live theater with Broadway shows, you'll want to put the American Music Theatre on your list.

This unique theater is family owned and offers you big-city entertainment in a beautiful small town. The theater is intimate, with only 1,600 seats, so you'll have enough legroom to stretch out during the show.

The American Music Theatre has over 200 live performances every year, with Oscar and Grammy award winners. 

There is a show for everyone, and over the next month, you can buy tickets for Amy Grant or Clint Black. The Temptations and the Beatles tribute RAIN are also great options.

Ticket prices range from $39 to $59, but this price varies depending on what show you decide to see.

Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre

The Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre is a popular 328-seat theater that offers musicals and fun children's productions year-round. The Dutch Apple has been open for 36 years and is owned by the Prather Family, who've been in theater for over 50 years.

The Lancaster location hosts well over 150,000 patrons annually and has various shows you can choose from. Currently, you can watch a musical about Elvis or enjoy the nostalgia of Footloose. Disney's Newsies is also a popular option for families.

You can have an authentic dinner buffet during most shows all week long. Dinner usually consists of a salad, vegetable side dishes, potatoes, prime rib, and of course, a sweet dessert.

Overall, the Dutch Apple Dinner Theatre is definitely a fun experience you'll want to add to your trip to-do list.

Ticket prices range from $22 to $80, depending on the show and time of day.

Fulton Theatre 

If you want some history with your theater, you'll want to check out the Fulton Theatre during your travels.

The Fulton Theatre is a National Historical Landmark in Lancaster County, and the building itself used to be a pre-revolutionary jail in the 1700s. The theater hall was built in 1852, but an exterior wall from the original jail still remains.

It also played a part in the Civil War, serving as an armory, hospital, and a point on the Underground Railroad.

The theater has been operating for more than 150 years, with many renovations during that time. Today, this theater has unique musical productions, like The Titanic, Robin Hood, and Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf.

There are also plenty of holiday shows, and family series shows that the entire family will love.

Tickets range in price depending on the show you see, and it's best to book in advance.

Magic & Wonder Dinner Theater

As far as performing arts and dinner shows go, you can't beat the Magic & Wonder Dinner Theater. You'll need to ensure this theater is at the top of your vacation itinerary.

This 350-seat theater has magically wonderful shows for people of all ages. The theater's star and owner, Master Illusionist Brett Myers, has entertained thousands of people and won the prestigious Merlin Award in 2021 for "Best Magic and Variety Show." Other recipients of the award include David Copperfield and Criss Angel.

There are exciting shows to choose from, like the Magical & Wonder Mystery Show, which features Brett and a talented cast exploring magical worlds like Atlantis and Neverland. You'll see amazing circus acts and impressive illusions that will take you to another place.

You can also watch Jukebox Jive and travel back in time to different eras like the 50s and 60s. The show consists of nostalgic hits from your school days with singing, dancing, comedy, and magic acts.

Winter Wonderland and Holly Jolly Jukebox will prepare you for the holiday season and remind you of your favorite holiday tunes.

Finally, you won't spend the night hungry, since dinner during the show is sure to please. Roasted chicken, pork barbecue, and homemade coleslaw are just some of the delicious options. The theater will even deliver your food right to your table during the show.

Dinner show tickets for adults are only $64.95, and tickets for children 4 to 12 are $34.95. Kids under four are free, and you'll pay different prices if you want to watch a show only. Be sure to check online for more prices and combo deals.

Visit the Magic & Wonder Dinner Theater in Lancaster, PA

Now that you have some options for theater in Lancaster, PA, you can begin making plans to attend the best shows.

You'll definitely need to buy tickets for the Magic & Wonder Dinner Theater so you don't miss out. From the food to the magical shows, this theater gives you an experience you won't forget.

Our theater is conveniently located by Best Western Revere Inn & Suites, and we offer bus parking if you're traveling in large groups.

Make sure you visit us online today to check out our upcoming shows and buy your tickets in advance!